Gillipedia Official Rating: With this movie’s logic, you’ll age 6 months reading this review. Hope it’s worth it.
Score: 7/10
Old is fun. I do have some
gripes that I’ll get into, but this is a bit of a return to form for M. Night
Shyamalan with one of the most unique premises in recent memory. 2 sets of
families take a vacation at a resort. When they wind up on a beach off the
beaten path, it doesn’t take long before our characters start acting strange
and they realize that this beach is rapidly aging them. They will desperately
try different methods unsuccessfully to escape as they race against the clock
to get off the beach and figure out why this is happening.
There’s a couple of recognizable
actors and actresses without any standout performances, and that works well
enough as the focus is on the character backgrounds and how that plays into the
overarching narrative. Shyamalan famously inserts himself into his movies, and
he gives himself one of the more important roles of the movie—which I think was
a bit too distracting. To give you a sense of how quickly the characters are
aging, each family has young children, and you can expect to see different
actors and actresses come in to represent the aging children.
One of the biggest focuses of the
story is trying to predict how the audience will discredit the film. What I
mean by this are the different thoughts we’ll all have. “Can they walk back
through the cliffside valley they came in from? How far out from civilization
are they if they swim?” These are the earliest questions you’ll think of and
unsurprisingly are the first aspects to be addressed by the film. As the
characters start showing the affects of aging, the questions become more
in-depth. “Well, wouldn’t they need lots of sustenance if their bodies are
aging? Are their minds aging, or is it just their bodies?” As you think more
philosophically, the film begins to show a couple of cracks or provide 1-2
sentences of dialogue to quickly explain something away. Probably the biggest
thing I’ll mention is that later on they do attempt to talk about what exactly
is happening on the beach. And it’s one of the stupidest jarbled nonsense of
science to make this film stay within the realm of realism.
The actual mystery behind the beach is
kind of dumb, but it’s not really a drag because the film keeps up a quick pace
as the situation grows more dire. But what is easily the worst aspect of the
film is how, including the mystery of the beach, the filmmakers felt like
everything had to have a tidy bow and try to be as crisp as possible with its
script and not trust the audience. Here’s probably the best example. A
character shown skinny dipping early in the morning on the beach washes up
while the 2 families are enjoying the beach, and that’s what kickstarts their
realization of something off. They find the dead body, and then a few hours
later, the body has reduced to bones already. The mom of the main family then
provides the audience a rough timeline of how an hour on the beach must
represent a few years on the beach; she explains how she comes to this conclusion because she works in a museum. And then everyone else's occupations explain how they know a specific detail of something too. Because
people obviously aren’t allowed to have any basis of knowledge of the world if
it isn’t directly tied who they are or what they do. The worst of this is from
a character named Jarin. He’s exposition central and constantly provides
one-sentence answers of what’s possible, what’s happening, or what they should
do. There’s a cool visual late in the movie that was foreshadowed from the
beginning of the beach, but in the middle of the visual, the character has to
explain what is happening in the moment instead of allowing the audience come
to that conclusion themselves. This is a relatively smart film that thinks the
audience is pretty stupid.
One thing that I briefly mentioned
earlier is the mental effects. And the film felt inconsistent to me on the kids
aging physically but staying the same mental age, but when the movie tries to
slow down for a second for us to catch our breaths, it’s like our adult
characters mature more with their age and settle the personal problems that
initially plagued them. The main draw of this film is the thriller nature of
rapid aging, but I feel like what could’ve pushed this film from fun thriller
to genuinely great film would be to explore the psyche of the characters
further. We see touches of this later in the film, but how the character
backstories tie in to the story could’ve provided some poignant moments where
the characters overcome the flaws that provided their motivation to come for a
relaxing vacation in the first place.
The film keeps at a great pace
overall, but it also could’ve ended 5 minutes sooner as the film gloats too
long about its ending and ties up all loose ends in predictable manners. How
everything actually does come together is pretty smart and some of the effects on
the characters are fun to see—like our adult characters starting to lose
hearing or vision and how that’s portrayed on the screen. This movie is a mix of
smart touches and over-explained plot points. It certainly has its flaws, but
it is undeniably entertaining and one of the more unique films you’ll be able
to find.